
For an old school, mafia-tinged throwback, Bamonte’s is the way to go.
The walls are covered in black and white family photos, as well as pictures of famous diners that have eaten here over the years—and many years these pictures represent, as Bamonte’s has been kicking it since 1900, making it one of New York’s oldest surviving restaurants. Plaques commemorate Bamonte’s 50th, 75th and 100th anniversary and are signed “From the Boys,” adding to its gangster appeal.
Once conventional and elegant, Bamonte’s now seems almost gimmicky, with its ancient, tuxedo-clad waiters, some who have worked here for 50 years, its chandeliers, wood telephone booths, white tablecloths and table-side buzzers, allowing customers to request the nearest silver-haired server.
Coming here is an old-fashioned experience, a time-travel of sorts. Upon entering, all you want to do is go home and get dressed up only to return, order a Manhattan and chain-smoke cigarettes, Mad Men style.
On an empty street, between the BQE and overgrown, empty lots, Bamonte’s is not much to look at; a typical two-story house on a mostly deserted block. However, customers are fiercely loyal, explaining Bamonte’s long life. It is a destination for milestones—weddings, graduations and birthdays are celebrated here daily. Sometimes all three are celebrated here by the same person, as one woman wrote on Yelp, substantiating Bamonte’s hold on its clientele.
The classic Italian menu is traditional and completely homemade, even the pasta. Chefs cook behind a glass window, their every movement visible to the customers. Beware of over-ordering, as the adequately priced portions are enormous, allowing you to have the same meal three or four times in the coming days.
The customers are a wild mix—groups that look like they have attended Bamonte’s opening, couples that seem like they’re about to get engaged, hipsters celebrating birthdays, family’s having their traditional Sunday dinner.
The places oozes a friendly camaraderie, a conviviality expressed by waiters and bartenders yelling hello at anyone entering, and making small talk with those at the bar as if they have known each other for years.
For anyone wanting to kick it old school, this is the place.
Bamonte’s
32 Withers St. btwn I-278 and Lorimer St., Willamsburg, Brooklyn.
718-384-8831
No website, it’s that old school.
Photo from nymag












